| New Hartford Firefighter | Date of Death | Years Served |
| Harry E. Inglis | February 3, 2009 | 16 |
| L. Daniel Callan | August 14, 2008 | 22 |
| Thomas C. Panzone | April 2, 2008 | 35 years |
| William F. Butler | May 1, 2007 | 30 |
| Michael D. Sowich | March 2, 2007 | 2 months |
| H. Seth Cornish | January 21, 2007 | 35 |
| Charles M. Ross, Sr | Aug 12, 2006 | 22 |
| Joseph D. Corr | February 27, 2006 | 11 |
| Gerald T. Darby | May 3, 2005 | 21 |
| William J. Lennon | February 17, 2005 | 15 |
| George S. Glass, Jr | January 25, 2005 | 50 |
| Harold G. Wentworth | July 26, 2004 | 19 |
| Robert E. Sherman | February 27, 2003 | 17 |
| Lawrence J. Goldbas | January 17, 2003 | 16 |
| William J. Freiberger, Jr | January 3, 2003 | 49 |
| Rev. Robert J. Conrad | October 26, 2002 | 15 |
| J. William Tenbrink, Jr | June 29, 2002 | 25 |
| Martin A. Madden | April 15, 2002 | 17 |
| John H. Witte | February 3, 2002 | 25 |
| Raymond P. Luker | May 20, 2001 | 19 |
| Thomas M. Doyle | March 9, 2001 | 19 |
| John A. Hoffman | August 31, 2000 | 28 |
| Russell W. Dunn | April 7, 2000 | 15 |
| John A. Kielar | March 23, 2000 | 21 |
| Stephen V. Scanlon, Jr | January 30, 2000 | 38 |
| Norton C. Stanton | June 19, 1999 | 25 |
| Harold C. Lewis | December 21, 1998 | 51 |
| Harry N. Hayes | December 2, 1998 | 21 |
| John E. Doyle | March 26, 1998 | 23 |
| Lionel J. LePage | March 24, 1998 | 21 |
| Joseph B. Kolb | July 21, 1997 | 40 |
| Gilbert P. Schulz | May 30, 1997 | 17 |
| Monroe B. Fox | January 10, 1996 | 23 |
| Leslie J. Dean | August 29, 1995 | 53 |
| Peter N. Hensel | January 28, 1995 | 17 |
| Dr. Ronald J. Goldstone | October 5, 1994 | 10 |
| Louis J. Sherwood | September 3, 1994 | 37 |
| Frederick W. Stewart | December 13, 1992 | 21 |
| Charles W. Ebensperger | September 8, 1992 | 17 |
| John W. Blumenstock | June 28, 1992 | 33 |
| J. Ralph Pugh | June 19, 1992 | 22 |
| Lesley F. Meeker | January 7, 1992 | 15 |
| Douglas A. Bowman | January 3, 1992 | 30 |
| Corlis R. Yahnke | December 23, 1991 | 20 |
| William G. Martin | October 23, 1991 | 40 |
| Bernard R. Wood | June 29, 1990 | 20 |
| Murphy J. Sherwood | May 21, 1990 | 24 |
| Robert A. Peckman | October 2, 1989 | 15 |
| Glenn E. Davies | March 31, 1989 | 19 |
| Roger J. Dillon | August 6, 1988 | 15 |
| Glenn A. Griffiths | February 23, 1988 | 16 |
| Burton W. Ambrose | October 14, 1987 | 34 |
| Tito J. Rappa | May 13, 1987 | 30 |
| Fred E. Luker, Jr | January 30, 1987 | 37 |
| Jerome K. Madden | June 11, 1986 | 15 |
| James B. Matteson | May 4, 1986 | 21 |
| Evan E. Roberts | January 20, 1984 | 16 |
| Richard M. Lockwood | November 25, 1983 | 11 |
| Edward Roman, Jr | March 29, 1983 | 41 |
| George J. Winn | June 9, 1982 | 25 |
| Carl E. Gill | December 12, 1981 | 1 |
| James A. Campbell | August 24, 1979 | 24 |
| Donald M. Kowalski | July 7, 1979 | 16 |
| John J. Salter | February 26, 1979 | 34 |
| Edward H. Hanley | December 10, 1978 | 65 |
| Reed J. Fancher | November 24, 1976 | 25 |
| J. Richard Williams | October 10, 1976 | 16 |
| Robert Dodge | February 13, 1974 | 21 |
| Chief James F. Mullen | September 23, 1973 | 2 |
| Dr Preston R. Clark | June 22, 1972 | 31 |
| William E. Inglis | February 13, 1972 | 40 |
| William V. Kelly | November 11, 1971 | 39 |
| Albert L. Matty | June 4, 1971 | 31 |
| Eldon W. Griffiths | September 7, 1970 | 18 |
| Leo C. Townsend | September 1, 1970 | 23 |
| Louis J. Billingham | May 28, 1970 | 7 |
| Robert O. Morris | February 16, 1970 | 49 |
| Stanley F. Renton | September 17, 1968 | 28 |
| Fred C. Stewart | July 6, 1966 | 29 |
| Bernard F. Green | October 30, 1965 | 21 |
| Milton A. Gaskell | October 5, 1965 | 41 |
| George F. Wadsworth | May 26, 1964 | 38 |
| Francis J. Frank | February 14, 1961 | 14 |
| Richard E. Shaw | December 19, 1959 | 6 |
| Thomas S. Wilson | November 28, 1959 | 42 |
| Albert R. Bolton | June 10, 1959 | 13 |
| Charles H. Williams | May 17, 1958 | 46 |
| Joseph A. Ferris | April 15, 1958 | 33 |
| Peter J. Hall | May 21, 1957 | 4 |
| William H. Doyle | April 11, 1954 | 1 |
| Alfred H. Hall | March 26, 1951 | 37 |
| William H. Roman | February 24, 1951 | 8 |
| Raymond F. Schafer | April 28, 1949 | 28 |
| Robert J. Campbell | July 13, 1947 | 11 |
| Robert E. Berg | May 28, 1947 | 2 |
| James F. Doyle | April 12, 1947 | 43 |
| Donald W. Hicks | September 4, 1944 | 3 |
| Frank A. Proctor | September 7, 1942 | 13 |
| John F. Seaton | May 1, 1942 | 8 |
| Carson B. Cunningham | October 11, 1941 | 24 |
| Joseph P. Corbett | September 30, 1941 | 39 |
| Wilbur G. Tovey | April 5, 1941 | 10 |
| Richard H. Yule | August 13, 1930 | 3 |
| Carl H. Rice | January 6, 1926 | 15 |
| Levi T. Cole | October 6, 1924 | 11 |
| George S. Corbett | July 9, 1920 | 11 |
| Francis G. Long | October 22, 1910 | 7 |
